Safety
with marine boilers
Marine boiler plants require adequate control systems to raise
steam, maintain design conditions for steady steaming, secure the boiler
units and detect promptly malfunctions and failures. The automatic control
arrangement on a shipboard boiler is divided into two parts:
|
Is an
automatic controlled boiler an explosion risk?
An easy way to find out if your boiler control system lights up
the first burner safely. Safely shut off the fuel supply to the burner before the test.
1. Power
up the boiler control system.
2. Start
the burner.
3. Start
a stopwatch when the combustion air damper has reached its maximum position.
4. Stop
the stopwatch when the combustion air damper begins to close again, and note
the purge time. The air in the furnace should be changed at least five times
during the prepurge period.
Find the furnace volume and the fan capacity from the documentation’s and calculate the purge time needed. The time must never be less than fifteen seconds even if your calculation says so.
5. Start
the stopwatch again when the automatic fuel oil shutoff valves open.
6. Stop
the stopwatch when the fuel oil shutoff valves close and you get a flame
failure or misfiring alarm, and note the trail-for-ignition time. If the time
you get is more than fifteen seconds, then you must not ignite the burner
ever, until the time has been adjusted. Five seconds is a relevant
trail-for-ignition time, but different classification societies specify
different maximum time. Get the correct maximum time from the rules of the
actual classification society.
N.B. This shut off delay is only allowed during trail-for-ignition. When you got at flame failure during normal firing the fuel oil valves must shut off instantly. Some further checks to improve the safety
1. The
fuel oil flow during light-up must not exceed 20% of the full load flow, but
in burners with limited turndown ratio the burners minimum load has to be
accepted.
2. A
corrupt flow transmitter signal may cause sever problems therefore:
·
When purging the furnace whit air prior
to light-up the position of the combustion air damper should be confirmed by
means of a limit switch rather than relying only on the air flow
transmitter's signal.
·
At burner light-up the position of the
fuel oil control valve and the combustion air damper should be confirmed by
means of limit switches rather than relying only on the flow transmitters'
signals. You should of course use the transmitters' signals, but they ought
to be confirmed to be reasonable by means of limit switches.
3. Direct
the light from a flashlight onto the flame scanner sensors, when the burner
is off, to confirm that the auto-check-function works correctly and you get
an alarm. If you get any other action, such as opening of the fuel valves,
then your system needs a thorough improvement.
4. Using
the igniter during the post-purge of the last burner's lance (or a single
burner's lance) has some disadvantages. Upon reset of the system, after a
flame failure, the igniter will start firing before the furnace has been
properly purged with air, which will cause impending risk of furnace
explosions. Consider the following:
·
A well-tried method is to purge the fuel
line and the burner-lance slowly to let the fuel continue to burn, without
igniter support, until the lance is empty.
·
Not purging the burner-lance at all is an
other method, but it requires a stand-by heating of the tubing and the lance
to keep the fuel sufficiently heated to be floating.
·
What ever you do, secure that the igniter
not under any circumstances starts before the furnace has been properly
purged with air.
Back to the question in the headline, is an automatic controlled boiler an explosion risk?
|
Fail-safe
systems
Any predictable failure must result in a safe situation.
How to make a control loop fail-safeExample: A simple control loop for pressure control of a steam boiler with one oil fired burner.
How to make a computerized control system fail-safe An output from a computer will become either high or low when it fails. There are some methods using the computer to check its own outputs. Feeding back an output’s signal to an input will enable the computer to check if the output is what it is supposed to be, but the system as a whole will not be fail-safe. The CPU or any other vital part might break down and then the check of the outputs is out of order. The only way to make a computer system fail-safe is to use an other computer to check all the functions. It is, of course, possible to check all the functions by means of hard wiring and relays, but who wants to do that? |
|||||
|
|
Beware
of fuel oil in the marine steam boilers feed water system.
The
marine steam boilers on board in ships nowadays have become a less evident
part of the engine room than they were in the old days. However, the marine
steam boilers are still important parts of the system, especially if the main
engines are running on heavy fuel oil that need to be heated. I don’t want to
go through the entire instruction book for the marine boiler but just point
out one important matter. As we all know, a very thin layer of oil on the surface of the boiler tubes or any of the direct heated surfaces of a boiler might cause local overheating of the material and possible damage to the boiler. What we maybe not know is how very small quantity of oil it requires to get a dangerous situation. A tube break in a fuel oil heat exchanger is very easy to detect, a simple detector in the hotwell will manage that, but a small crack in a tube may cause you an even more serious problem. A tiny oil leakage giving some 15 to 25 ppm of oil in the boiler feed water would not be visible; the water is still limpid. Yet this apparently insignificant oil pollution might causes sever danger to the boiler. If a boiler has a capacity of 20 tons of steam per hour at full load and the feed water is polluted with 25 ppm of oil, then it will accumulate approximately 12 kg oil in the steam drum per day. A bucket of oil in the boiler every day; I suggest that you buy yourself a sensitive oil detector. It will cost you, but it might save you from some future cost of repairs. One can say that you will get fewer buckets for your bucks. N.B. ppm=parts per million. 1 ppm=1kg per 1000 metric tons or 1 ppm=2 lb. per 1000 short tons. An oily ring inside the water gauge glasses at the water level is a serious warning. |
Harmful
Substances in Boiler Feed Water.
The mineral and organic substances present in natural water
supplies vary greatly in their relative proportions, but are principally
comprised under the carbonates, sulphates and chlorides of lime, magnesia and
sodium, iron and aluminum salts, silicates, mineral and organic acids, and
the gases oxygen and carbon dioxide.Scale is formed from the carbonates and sulphates of lime and magnesia, and from the oxides of iron, aluminum and silicon and it will result in:
A very thin scale can cause tube failure due to overheating. Scale has about one-fortyeighth of the heat conductivity of steel. A scale thickness of about 1 mm (0.04") can be sufficient to reduce the heat transportation to a dangerous point; when the water inside the tube cannot receive and carry away the heat fast enough from the tube metal to keep its temperature below its fusion temperature, resulting in the tubes "burning-out". |
Feedwater
heating has a number of advantages:
Using an open or direct contact feedwater heater, where the
water is raised to near-steam temperature is the most effective, the cheapest
and the most convenient system of de-aeration.Heating boiler feed water by means of exhaust steam effects a saving of about 1% of fuel for each 6ºC rise in the temperature of the feed water. Consequently, heating the water from 10° to 99ºC saves about 14% fuel. Besides the fuel saving, heating the feed water increases the actual steaming capacity of the boilers. Using surplus of exhaust steam, above that required for heating the boiler feed water, to heat buildings will realize additional economies. If all of the exhaust steam from engines or turbines can be utilized for heating during the heating season, it will pay to shut down the condenser. The first and most important use for the exhaust steam is to heat the feed water, since all of the heat of the exhaust steam so utilized returns undiminished to the boilers.
Some other
valuable advantages:
|
Steam
boiler water level sensors
Differential pressure measuring transmitter.This method uses normally a differential pressure measuring system with "wet leg", that is, the impulse pipes to the positive measuring point below the lowest water level and the impulse pipe to the negative measuring point above the highest water level, are both filled with water. The differential pressure signal is normally elevated so the output signal corresponds to the level in the boiler. 0% of water in the level glass correspond to 4 mA (3 psi) and 100% corresponds to 20 mA (15 psi). The measuring result is insensitive to foam in the boiler drum since the measuring method is based on the weight of the water. |
Capacitance measuring electrode transmitter. An insulated electrode is placed in the boiler and the length should be sufficient to reach the water at all acceptable levels. The insulated electrode and the boiler work as a capacitor with the water and the steam as a variable dielectric medium. The capacitance of the ”capacitor” is converted into a current signal. 0% of water in the level glass corresponds to 4 mA and 100% corresponds to 20 mA. The measuring result is rather sensitive to foam in the boiler and deposits on the electrode influences negatively on the measuring results. This method is relatively new as level control in steam boilers although it has been used for a long time for dry substances such as grains in warehouses. |
Conductivity measuring electrode level switch. An electrode is placed in the steam dome and the length of the electrode decides the level where the alarm shall occur. A low voltage alternating current passes through the water in the boiler to the electrode and the circuit breaks when the water level falls below the end of electrode. This method is mainly used for high and low level alarms. It is also used, in small size boilers, to start and stop the feed water pumps. Deposit on the electrode is not a problem. Normal degree of coverage does not disturb the measuring results. The measuring result is sensitive to dense foam in the boiler. It’s normally one electrode for emergency low water level alarm, or two electrodes if also high level alarm is required. This water level sensing method is also common on small boilers for start and stop of the feed water pumps. Up to six electrodes can be used in one electrode stand. |
Level float switch. Level float switches have been used for decades as level switches in boilers, but nowadays electrodes have replaced them. Moving parts are hard to check in boilers and deposit on the hinge may seriously disturb the function. The measuring result is rather insensitive to foam in the boiler. |
Level float transmitter. A level displacer (a float heavier than the water) is suspended to a spring balance by means of a stainless steel cable or a rod. When semi-submerged the weight of the displacer changes when the water level varies and the change in weight is converted into a level signal that corresponds to the level in the boiler. 0% of water in the level glass correspond to 4 mA (3 psi) and 100% corresponds to 20 mA (15 psi). This level measuring method is not so very common onboard ships since the measuring result is very influenced by the ship’s movement. Ashore, on the other hand, it works very well. |
Steam
boiler water level control
In a boiler drum exist water and steam at saturation pressure
and saturation temperature. Furthermore, the water is mixed with steam
bubbles in different sizes. If one opens the valve to a steam consumer then
the pressure in the boiler drum falls and hence the steam bubbles expand and
the water level rises despite the fact that the water mass actually
decreases. On the other hand, pumping in cold feed water will cause the steam
bubbles to collapse and the water level falls when the water quantity
actually increases in the steam drum. These shrinks and swell phenomena will
complicate the control of the boilers steam drum level. For a boiler with large amount of water and relatively low steam production a single water level transmitter on the steam drum is sufficient for the level controller to maintain a level with acceptable variation. Far more sophisticated methods are required for boilers with high steam production and relatively small water volume. The classic method works as follow: The outlet steam-mass is measured and the inlet feed-water-mass is adjusted to the very same amount. The level transmitter is merely used to tune up the system so the water level lies within the limits. Thus, the setpoint to the feed water flow controller is the sum of the outlet steam flow signal and the reversed water level controllers signal minus 12 mA (or 9 psi if it is a pneumatic system). |
Add to the monthly maintenance list:
|
Two-boilers
operation
Keeping a slave boiler pressurized.In a two-boiler system it’s often a problem to keep the slave boiler at operation pressure when the steam demand is low. This problem does not appear when the vessel is loading or unloading in a harbor since those operations normally need both boilers. On the other hand, when the ship is at sea and only one oil-fired boiler is used then the slave boiler tends to cool down far below the required stand by conditions. Different methods have been used to solve this problem. Installing steam heating coils in the bottom of the boiler is one method and a sophisticated start-and-stop method for the slave boiler’s burner to keep the pressure at desired level is an other. These installations will be unnecessary if you happened to have an exhaust gas economizer. Just connect the exhaust gas economizer to the slave boiler instead of the master boiler. This operation method will guaranty normal operation pressure on both boilers all the time at sea. The method has been used in many ships and the chief engineers are satisfied with the result. |
Hydrazine
A colorless fuming liquid, N2H4, derived from diazoacetic acid:
used as a reducing agent in organic synthesis and as a fuel in jet engines.Used in a boiler, to reduce oxygen in the system, the normal level of hydrazine reserve to be maintained in the water is between 0.1 and 0.3 ppm. The chemical reaction with oxygen can be expressed as: N2H4 + O2 ==> 2H2O + N2 Excess hydrazine, in a boiler, breaks down to produce ammonia that has beneficial effects in raising the pH of the steam/condensate system and thus affords some protection to the system by neutralizing any carbon dioxide. The reaction can occur in two ways: 3N2H4 ==> 4NH3+ N2 2N2H4 ==> 2NH3 + N2 + H2 Hydrazine should be handled with care since it is carcinogenic and allergenic. |
|
|
|
A.
Fuel Oil header
The Fuel Oil header should be a standing up relatively large pipe with a deaeration pipe to a higher level than the fuel oil service tanks; some times it's connected to the top of the diesel oil service tank.
B.
Fuel Oil filters
Clean the Fuel Oil filter frequently. If the filters are clogged the fuel oil might vaporize in the pump and cause damage. A differential pressure meter across the filter would be a good help to have the filters cleaned in time.
D.
Fuel Oil pumps
Each pump should have sufficient capacity to run both boilers on maximum load. Normally one pump is running and the other is standing-by. The stand-by pump should start upon low pressure in the process line rather than being started upon a pump motor failure.
E.
Shut off non return valves
These valves have to be non-return type, or a shut off valve and a non-return valve. The valves should always be open on both pumps, so the stand-by pump can start automatically.
F.
Fuel Oil heater
The fuel oil heater is a heat exchanger that must have a safety relief valve. Always install a safety relief valve if a fuel oil volume can be shut up and heated.
1.
Change over valve, Heavy Fuel Oil to
Diesel Oil
The three-way valve ought to be provided with a limit switch that breaks the electric circuit and shut off the fuel oil heating valve, in the control loop 3 , avoiding the diesel oil from being heated over its flashpoint.
2.
Fuel oil pressure control
The pressure control loop adjusts the fuel oil pressure by means of the pressure controller and the fuel oil return valve. The pressure is measured after the fuel oil heater to get accurate pressure to the burners. The return valve before the fuel oil heater recycles cold fuel to protect the pumps from overheating.
3.
Fuel oil temperature control
The temperature control loop adjusts the fuel oil temperature by means of the temperature controller and the steam inlet control valve. The temperature controller's set point should be set to assure an adequate fuel oil viscosity for the actual burners. Sometimes the control valve is installed in the condensate outlet line. This requires a smaller control valve and the control function works even better. However, this installation is for some reason not so very common.
4.
Fuel oil flow control
On large boilers the fuel oil flow controller gets its setpoint from the burner management system or the airflow controller to achieve a proper air-fuel mixture. On smaller boilers the fuel oil flow control valve often is connected to the combustion air damper by means of a metal rod or wire. In both cases the steam pressure in the boiler sets a suitable fuel oil flow.
5.
Fuel oil shut of valves
Almost every classification society and other authorities requires two shut of valves for the fuel oil, mechanically in series and electrically in parallel.
6.
Fuel oil recirculation valve
This valve does not always exist, but if it does, the valve should open when the fuel oil shut of valves closes. The recirculation has advantages and disadvantages.
·
The advantage is that it keeps the fuel
oil line warm when the burner is off.
·
The disadvantages is that it will, in the
long run, heat up the fuel oil passing through the oil pump that might cause
problem with cavitations.
Leading the recirculation fuel oil back to the fuel oil service
tank wouldn't be wise. The fuel oil's temperature often exceeds 120ºC and
water that might occur at the bottom of the tank will vaporize and in
worst-case cause damage to the tank.
|
A. Economizer
section
Preheats the circulating water before it enters the evaporator tubes.
B. Evaporator section
Water evaporates and emulsion of steam and water flows back to the boiler.
C. Superheater
section
Superheats the steam for the turbine.
D. Heat exchanger
Preheats the boiler feedwater.
E. Condenser
The exhaust steam from the turbine and excess steam from the steam system condense and recycle.
F. Condensate pump
1. Steam pressure
control
The pressure control loop adjusts the burner load according the steam demand.
2. Water level
control
A simple control loop will do for a boiler with large amount of water and relatively small steam output. To minimize shrink and swell at start and stop of the burner it would be wise to have two setpoints for the water level. A lower level (abt. 40%) when the burner is stop and a higher (abt. 50%) when it's firing.
3. Economizer inlet
temperature control
The feedwater is pre-heated in order to increase the efficiency of the plant. The circulating water to the exhaust gas boiler heats the feed water and the three-way valve on the inlet to the heat-exchanger controls the temperature. The economizer inlet temperature must never fall below 135°C to avoid corrosion on the economizer-tubes.
4. Condenser
pressure control
An absolute pressure transmitter and a controller adjust the cooling-water to the condenser to protect the condensate from being cooled down more than necessary.
5. Condenser level
control
The level controller actuates the condensate outlet control valve.
6. Feedwater tank
level control
The level controller actuates the make up water control valve. |
Burner fuel-oil-atomizing methods
Pressure jet atomizerThe pressure jet atomizer utilizes the supply pressure energy to atomize the fuel into a spray of finely dispersed droplets. Provided adequate fuel pressure is used, extremely good combustion results can be achieved. The fuel oil is fed into the swirl chamber by means of the tangential ports in the main atomizer body. An air core is set up due to the vortex formed in the swirl chamber; this results in the fuel leaving the final orifice as a thin annular film. This film of fuel has angular as well as axial velocity causing the fuel to develop into a hollow con as it discharges from the orifice. This type of atomizer has a poor turn down ratio. A small drop in atomizing pressure will result in a dramatic reduction in combustion performance. Two or three nozzles are sometimes fitted to achieve turn down, one in use on low fire, two on medium fire and three for full rate firing. A variation of the pressure jet atomizer is spill return or recirculating burner. The problems with this type of burner are that the atomizer has an increasing cone angle of the issuing spray as the burner is turned down with impingement on the furnace walls, being made possible and the additional problem of how to dispose of the returned hot oil if the burner has been running for prolonged periods on low fire. External mix steam atomizer or Steam-assisted pressure jet atomizer The steam-assisted pressure jet atomizer is designed to make full use of pressure jet atomization at high outputs and full use of blast atomization at low outputs. The atomizer consists of a conventional simplex type of pressure jet tip, around which is provided steam supply passage. Steam issues through an annular gap after being provided with the correct degree of swirl to ensure that the steam-exit angle matches the oil-spray cone angle. The steam-supply pressure remains constant throughout the complete turndown range of the burner. No mixing of fuel oil and steam occurs within the burner-gun and hence oil o~tput is unaffected by slight variations in the steam pressure. Internal mix steam atomizer The burner lance consists of two concentric tubes, a one-piece nozzle and a sealing nut. The media supplies are arranged so that the steam is supplied down the center tube and the fuel oil through the outer tube. Consequently, the steam space is completely isolated from the oil space. The steam atomizer consists of an atomizer body that has a number of discharge nozzles arranged on a pitch circle in such a way that each oil bore meets a corresponding steam bore in a point of intersection. Oil and steam (air) mix internally forming an emulsion of oil and steam at high pressure. The expansion of this mixture as it issues from the final orifice produces a spray of finely atomized oil. Oil burners with steam atomizing are tolerant to viscosity changes. In addition to this advantage, the steam atomized oil burners have better turn down, do not require high fuel oil pump pressures, and are frugal in the use of steam. Rotary cup atomizer The rotary cup is driven at high speed (about 5000 RPM) by an electric motor via a heavy-duty belt drive. The fuel oil flows at low pressure into the conical spinning cup where it distributes uniformly on the inner surface and throws off the cup rim as a very fine oil film. A primary air fan discharges the primary air concentrically around the cup, strikes the oil film at high velocity and atomizing it into tiny droplets.The rotary cup burner finds considerable use on packaged shell type boilers. These burners have good turn down ratio and they are rather insensitive to pollutants in the fuel oil.
Low pressure air atomizer
The principle is similar to that of the rotary-cup-atomizing, but the fuel is forced to rotate in a fixed cup by means of a forcefully rotating primary airflow. Their general construction makes them suitable for firing into chambers of hot brickwork, avoiding all the hazards of back radiation to oil burners of more delicate construction. Low pressure air atomizers imply air up to 1000 mm WG. (40 ins. WG.).
Blue flame burner
In the blue flame burner some of the hot gases from the flame are circulated back to the inlet where they mix with and heat the combustion air. The fuel oil is, during normal firing, introduced into the hot recirculating gases and vaporizes. When the hot flue gases and gaseous fuel mix with the combustion air it burns with a blue flame without visible smoke. This is the closest to stoichiometric combustion one can get with a commercial burner today. Oilon once made small size blue flame burners without ceramic material and only one fuel nozzle. |
Sludge
firing
A few words about firing sludge in a boiler furnace. Is the sludge a waste just to get rid of or is it a valuable fuel? Well, it’s both. It’s waste oil that you want to get rid of, but it contains energy that you ought to utilize. The sludge has to be conditioned to form a smooth emulsion with between 20% and 30% of water. Circulating the content of the sludge service tank with a large pump and, if necessary, add some water will be a useful method. The percentage of water might be measured by means of a capacitive electrode in the pipe downstream the circulation pump. The measuring method has some disadvantages, but it works. The temperature of the emulsion should be adjusted to achieve the viscosity recommended by the burner maker, but it mustn't exceed the boiling point of the water. It’s normally difficult to fire pure sludge; it has to be mixed with normal fuel oil. The sludge/fuel oil ratio depends on the sludge quality. With a really poor sludge you can only fire about 10% sludge. With a better, well-mixed sludge the ratio could be higher, but the burner has to be continuously supervised, since it’s very difficult to get a homogeneous sludge-mixture and the air demand may change suddenly. There is no problem to fire sludge with this method. The problem is that sludge contains a great portion of ash and nonburnable sediments that accumulates on the surfaces of the furnace. Increased soot-cleaning is strongly advised. |
Smoke Density Monitor
It is very easy to achieve a smokeless fire without any special
equipment for supervision. On the other hand, to achieve a smokeless fire and
economic combustion will be a bit harder. The air supply has to be slightly
in excess of the theoretical requirements. That is, the combustion air flow
is reduced almost to the smoke limit. A plant that never shows traces of smoke
at the chimney is not burning the fuel efficiently.There are four instruments that will help you to achieve the optimal combustion:
1. Smoke
Density Monitor. High smoke density indicates uneconomical combustion and
it might also cause penalty from the environmental protecting authorities.
2. O2 -
Analyzer. High O2 content indicates heating of unnecessary high
quantity of combustion air.
3. CO -
Analyzer. High CO content indicates unburned hydrocarbons. This is
not only uneconomical, the CO is also harmful to mans health. Besides, mixed
with air, CO might be an explosion risk.
4. CO2 -
Analyzer. Low CO2 content indicates poor combustion, but it doesn’t
tell if more or less air is required.
The most important instrument, the Smoke Density Monitor,
happened to be the cheapest of them and you can’t do without it if you are
trying to optimize the combustion of your burners. The equipment is very simple. A light beam is sent across the flue duct, from a light emitter to a light receiver. An electronic unit monitors the opacity. It indicates 0% if there is no black smoke present and 100% if the light beam is totally absorbed by the smoke. An alarm activates if the smoke density exceeds the preset limit. Some advises:
|